On 27 and 28 September 2026 we asked Perplexity "best <profession> in <town>, UK" and logged every answer: 496 answers to 456 distinct questions, covering 105 professions and shop types.
How it was measured
Each answer was saved with the firms it named and the source links shown inside the answer text. Perplexity ran in basic mode and we did not expand the full source panel, so the counts below are the links visible in the answer itself.
What we found
- Answers name a handful of firms. The median answer named 5 firms (range 0 to 14). Only 3 of 496 answers named no firm at all.
- Directories and review sites appear in most answers. 410 of 496 answers (about 4 in 5) cited at least one of the 19 general directory and review sites on our list (Yell, Bark, Trustpilot, thebestof and similar). For 8 answers these 19 sites made up more than half of the sources. The list does not include profession-specific sites such as fresha.com, getagent.co.uk or houzz.co.uk (point 4), so both numbers are a lower bound.
- The most-cited sites. trustpilot.com appeared in 190 answers, yell.com in 87, yelp.com in 82, whatclinic.com in 60, checkatrade.com in 59, and doctify.com, fresha.com and trustatrader.com in 54 each (of 496).
- In five of the professions we asked about most, one or two sites lead. Physiotherapists: fresha.com in 31 of 55 answers. Accountants: businessfinancing.co.uk in 26 of 48. Dentists: bestdentists.uk and mynextdentist.co.uk in 21 of 31 each. Estate agents: getagent.co.uk in 24 of 26. Architects: houzz.co.uk in 23 of 25.
- Official registers show up. 67 of 496 answers cited a professional register, regulator, professional body or gov.uk page (ICAEW, SRA, CQC, FCA, Law Society, RICS, RIBA's Find an Architect, Companies House and similar; full list below the table). For 6 of them the only such link was a local council, parish or nidirect page. Separately, nhs.uk appeared in 41 answers, more than Facebook or Instagram (38) and far more than Reddit (3).
- Google Maps never appeared in the answer text. 0 of 496 answers linked to Google Maps or Google Search. One linked to a Google Business page (business.google.com) and one to a site hosted on Google Sites (sites.google.com).
- "Best of" list pages show up. 52 of the 250 answers for which we had full source URLs cited a page whose address contains "best-" or "top-", most of them directory or local-guide list pages.
- The same question gives a different list a few hours later. 40 questions were asked twice on 28 September, about 3 hours apart. Only 3 of the 40 pairs named the same firms; on average 48% of the firms named in a pair appeared in both answers. Of 324 named firms across those pairs, 179 appeared in only one of the two answers.
All findings in one table
| Finding | Number | Out of | How we counted |
|---|---|---|---|
| Firms named per answer | median 5, range 0 to 14 | 496 answers | firms listed in the answer text |
| Answers that named no firm | 3 | 496 answers | |
| Sources per answer | median 15 | 496 answers | links shown inside the answer text |
| At least one directory or review site | 410 | 496 answers | 19 general directory and review sites (listed below the table) |
| Directories are more than half of the sources | 8 | 496 answers | |
| Cites trustpilot.com | 190 | 496 answers | exact domain; country sites such as ie.trustpilot.com not counted (they add 14 answers for Trustpilot) |
| Cites yell.com | 87 | 496 answers | exact domain |
| Cites yelp.com | 82 | 496 answers | exact domain |
| Cites whatclinic.com | 60 | 496 answers | exact domain |
| Cites checkatrade.com | 59 | 496 answers | exact domain |
| Cites doctify.com | 54 | 496 answers | exact domain |
| Cites fresha.com | 54 | 496 answers | exact domain |
| Cites trustatrader.com | 54 | 496 answers | exact domain |
| Cites a register, regulator or other gov.uk page | 67 | 496 answers | find.icaew.com, sra.org.uk, gdc-uk.org, rics.org, cqc.org.uk, hcpc-uk.org, csp.org.uk, optical.org, lawsociety.org.uk, fca.org.uk, ciat.global, architects-register.org.uk, architecture.com, any *.gov.uk; arb.org.uk, rcvs.org.uk and riba.org are not on the list, so this is a lower bound |
| Cites nhs.uk | 41 | 496 answers | nhs.uk and NHS trust subdomains |
| Cites Facebook or Instagram | 38 | 496 answers | |
| Cites Reddit | 3 | 496 answers | |
| Cites Google Maps or Google Search | 0 | 496 answers | maps.google.* or google.* (Google Business and Google Sites pages counted separately) |
| Cites a Google Business page | 1 | 496 answers | business.google.com |
| Cites a Google Sites page | 1 | 496 answers | sites.google.com |
| Cites a "best" or "top" list page | 52 | 250 answers with full source URLs | page address contains "best-" or "top-" |
| Same question asked twice: identical firm list | 3 | 40 pairs | same 40 questions asked again on 28 September |
| Same question asked twice: average overlap of firm lists | 48% | 40 pairs | shared firms / all firms named in the pair |
| Same question asked twice: firms in only one of the two answers | 179 | 324 named firms |
The 19 directory and review sites: yell.com, bark.com, thebestof.co.uk, trustpilot.com, yelp.co.uk, yelp.com, checkatrade.com, threebestrated.co.uk, freeindex.co.uk, 192.com, cylex-uk.co.uk, scoot.co.uk, hotfrog.co.uk, whatclinic.com, doctify.com, reviewsolicitors.co.uk, find.icaew.com, ratedpeople.com, mybuilder.com.
Registers, regulators and gov.uk: find.icaew.com, sra.org.uk, gdc-uk.org, rics.org, cqc.org.uk, hcpc-uk.org, csp.org.uk, optical.org, lawsociety.org.uk, fca.org.uk, ciat.global, architects-register.org.uk, architecture.com and any *.gov.uk page.
Columns in the CSV
- answer_no, date, query, profession, town
- the question as asked, split into profession and town; date of the run
- mode
- Perplexity mode; blank where it was not recorded (16 answers on 27 September)
- firms_named, sources_cited
- how many firms the answer named and how many source links it showed
- full_source_urls_saved
- 1 = full source URLs were saved (28 September); 0 = site names only (27 September)
- any_directory_or_review_site, directories_over_half_of_sources
- 1 = at least one of the 19 directory sites; 1 = they made up more than half of the sources
- cites_<domain>
- 1 = the answer cited that exact domain
- cites_register_regulator_or_gov_uk, cites_nhs_uk, cites_facebook_or_instagram, cites_reddit
- 1 = the answer cited a site of that type (lists above)
- cites_google_maps_or_google_search, cites_google_business_page, cites_google_sites_page
- maps.google.* or google.*; business.google.com; sites.google.com
- cites_best_or_top_list_page
- 1 = a cited page address contains "best-" or "top-"; blank = full URLs not saved (27 September)
- asked_twice_pair_id, pair_*
- filled only for the 40 questions asked twice; pair_overlap_share = shared firms / all firms named in the pair; pair_firms_total = all firms named in the pair; pair_firms_in_only_one_answer = firms named in only one of the two answers
The data behind every number on this page: answers-496.csv (one row per answer, 496 rows). Each row has the question, profession, town, date, how many firms were named and how many sources were cited, and 1/0 flags for the sites and site types above. Firm names and the firms' own websites are left out. Questions asked twice share a pair number. The columns are described above.
What this means for a local business
- If your profession is one of the five in point 4, check your listing on the site that leads for it: in our sample it was the source cited most often for that profession.
- If your profession has a register or regulator listing, make sure your entry there is complete and current (point 5).
- Being named once is not a result. Because lists change between runs (point 8), visibility has to be measured repeatedly, not checked once.
Limits
One engine (Perplexity), one country (UK), two days. Basic mode with inline citations only; the full source panel was not expanded. The SEO-agency runs we also made (30 cities) are a separate study and are not included in these numbers.
We chose the professions and towns ourselves; they are not a random sample of UK businesses, so the counts describe these 496 answers, not all local searches. Full source URLs were saved only for the 250 answers on 28 September; for 27 September we saved site names only. For 16 answers (27 September) the mode was not recorded.